Ethics violations of the Editors’ Code in the print media for year 2021 monitored by the PCCSL

Ethics violations of the Editors’ Code in the print media for year 2021 monitored by the PCCSL

The Dispute Resolution Council of the Press Complaints Commission of Sri Lanka released the violations of the Editors’ Code, monitored by the PCCSL Secretariat, for the Year 2021 published in national newspapers in Sinhala, Tamil and English languages. There were in all 64 violations for the Year under review.   Of the 64 violations, Clause

The Dispute Resolution Council of the Press Complaints Commission of Sri Lanka released the violations of the Editors’ Code, monitored by the PCCSL Secretariat, for the Year 2021 published in national newspapers in Sinhala, Tamil and English languages. There were in all 64 violations for the Year under review.

 

Of the 64 violations, Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing had 55 violations, Clause 7. Privacy had 06 violations and Clause 2. Accurate Reporting had 03 violations.

 

Clause 2. Accurate Reporting – total 3 violations

 

Sub Clause 2.1: The media must take all reasonable care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorting news. (3 violations).

 

  1. General Reporting and Writing – total 55 violations

 

Sub clause 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest. (14 violations).

 

Sub Clause 6.2: In reporting accounts of crime or criminal case, publications shall not, unless it is both legally permitted and in the public interest – (4 violations)

 

6.2 (i). Name victims of sex crimes. (2 violations).

 

Sub Clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story. (22 violations)  

 

Sub clause 6.5: Excessive details of suicide given in story. (13 violations)

 

Clause 07. Privacy – total 6 violations

 

Sub Clause 7.1: The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals. (6 violations).

 

The Dispute Resolution Council has repeatedly informed editors and journalist through the PCCSL that they must be more vigilant at the stage of copy editing to prevent hurt for the individual concerned and embarrassment for the newspaper when it is pointed out.

 

Please see detail chart of violations below.

 

January

Nothing to report

 

February

Date Description of violation Clause violated
Feb. 02, 2021 Usage of the word ‘Muslim’ to describe a man. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Feb. 03, 2021 Reference to a doctor treating COVID-19 patients who has died as, ‘Corona Doctor’. Clause 2. Accurate Reporting.
Sub Clause 2.1: The media must take all reasonable care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorting news.

 

March

Date Description of violation Clause violated
March 01, 2021 Photograph of female LTTE child soldier along with Mrs. Balasingham. Facial features recognizable and not mentioned that it is an old file photograph. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
March 04, 2021 Photograph of headless murdered woman in traveling bag. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
March 04, 2021 Photograph of headless murdered woman in traveling bag. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
March 04, 2021 Steps of suicide of Police SI who is main suspect in murder of woman in traveling bag, given. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5:  Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
March 09, 2021  Details of suicide by father of 4 children given. He used a bed sheet to hang himself from a bridge. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5:  Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
March 10, 2021  Muslim Principal of Tamil School sexually abuses girl. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
March 07 & 14, 2021

respectively

Suicide photo of man hanging from a tree. He is the main suspect in murdered woman in travelling bag. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing

Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.

March 12, 2021 Lead story of Muslim businessman burned in his car. Clause 06. General reporting and writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
March 19, 2021 Photograph of dead drug lord, ‘Keselwatte Dinuka’, in Dubai. Face is visible with cotton wool stuffed in nose Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
March 25, 2021  Substance consumed in suicide mentioned. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
March 26, 2021 Published photos of two burn bodies of husband and wife in addition to excessive details of suicide given. story Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing

Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.

March 27, 2021 Published photos of two burn bodies of husband and wife in addition to excessive details of suicide given. story Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing

Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.

 

April  

Date Description of violation Clause violated
April 06, 2021 Girl (15) gives birth to baby. Name of School in Hatton and class Grade 11 mentioned  Clause 07. Privacy
Sub Clause 7.1: The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals.
April 06, 20211 Girl (5) raped by boy (15). Details leading to identity of victim given.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause 6.2: In reporting accounts of crime or criminal case, publications shall not, unless it is both legally permitted and in the public interest – 6.2 (i). Name victims of sex crimes.

 

May

Date Description of violation Clause violated
May 06, 2021

 

Publish photos of killed underworld leader Riyad.

Bleeding and injured body.

Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
May 07, 2021 Story about nomination of new Attorney General. Name was proposed to the President by the Parliamentary Council and not the Constitutional Council. Clause 2. Accurate Reporting.
Sub Clause 2.1: The media must take all reasonable care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorting news.

 

June

Date Description of violation Clause violated
June 01 The body of a Muslim woman was taken to Batticaloa for cremation.  Mentioned her as a Muslim women. Clause 06. General reporting and writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
June 04 An incident was described in-depth giving rise to emotional and painful feelings. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
June 13 Misleading information concerning date of lifting of lock down. However, lockdown was extended. Clause 02. Accuracy
Sub Clause 2.1: The media must take all reasonable care not to publish inaccurate, misleading or distorting news.
June 27 Article mentions that two Tamil people along with a Sub Inspector were arrested with a haul of drugs. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
June 27 Article mentions that two Tamil people along with a Sub Inspector were arrested with a haul of drugs. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
June 28 Headline says, Corona lady in Bibile Hospital bitten by dog dies.  Clause 07. Privacy
Sub Clause 7.1: The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals.
June 28  Headline says dog bites two Corona ladies in Morawaka Hospital.  Clause 07. Privacy
Sub Clause 7.1: The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals.
June 29 Muslim woman caught selling drugs in Negombo. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   

 

July

Date Description of violation Clause violated
July 11, 2021 Sri Lankan Tamil Woman commits suicide by jumping in front of a train. 

Mention of Tamil (race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
July 12, 2021.  Muslim doctor took photos of lady doctor having a bath in the hostel.

Mention of Muslim (race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 12, 2021.

 

Muslim doctor took photos of lady doctor having a bath in the hostel.

Mention of Muslim (race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 18, 2021.

 

Two Muslim businessman also involved in rape case of under-aged girl (15).

Mention of Muslim(race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 20, 2021 Large photograph of LTTE child soldiers published. The faces are recognisable. Nowhere is it mentioned that it is a library photograph and the eyes blackened.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub clause: 6.1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
July 20, 2021, Muslim woman collecting  information in COVID-19 center. Mention of Muslim(race) Clause 6.1: General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 20, 2021,

 

Muslim woman collecting  information in COVID-19 center. Mention of Muslim(race) Clause 6.1: General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 21, 2021,  Girl commits suicide following rape by father by eating Niyagala seeds. Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
July 21, 2021,  Wariyapola student commits suicide because of difficulty in studying online. She hanged herself. Details of hanging given. Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
July 23, 2021 Melbourne couple jailed for enslaving Tamil woman.

 Mention of Tamil (race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
July 28, 2021  Tamil boy killed in Australian Fire.

Mention of Tamil

(race)

Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   

 

August

Date Description of violation Clause violated
August 19 Describe suicide story in the house Clause 6.General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.

 

September

Date Description of violation Clause violated
Sept. 08, 2021 Mention of missing woman (25) in Nuwara Eliya as a Tamil person. Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Sep 15, 2021  Hand grenade in the wash room in Lanka Hospital. Use of word Tamil boy, from Trincomalee arrested. Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Sep 16, 2021  Trincomalee Tamil boy arrested regarding bomb case in Narahenpita Hospital Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Sep 16, 2021  Trincomalee Tamil boy arrested regarding bomb case in Narahenpita Hospital Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Sep 22, 2021,  Husband remanded killed Corona wife Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause: 6.4 (ii): ii. It must avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion, sexual orientation, physical or mental illness or disability unless these are directly relevant to the story. 
Sept. 28, 2021 A young female doctor died in London due to drowning mentioned as a Tamil. Clause 6. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   

 

October

Date Description of violation Clause violated
Oct. 05,2021  Excessive details given in story about man who committed suicide by hanging himself with the use of a bed sheet in Gothatuwa.   Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Oct. 07, 2021  Millionaire Tamil businessman arrested over Sathosa garlic scam.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   
Oct. 07, 2021,  Three people handling cots were promoted to DIG.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause 6.4: (i): The press must avoid prejudicial or pejorative reference to a person’s race, colour, religion, sex
Oct. 13, 2021,  Steps explained of how a student committed suicide in the kitchen.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Oct. 13, 2021,  Steps explained of how a student committed suicide in the kitchen.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Oct. 14, 2021

 

Photograph of dead infant 1 ½ months old. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause: 6. 1:The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest. 
Oct. 15, 2021 Two Iranian nationals commit suicide drinking alcohol-based sanitizer.
The word ‘sanitizer’ should not be used.
Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Oct. 18, 2021 Photograph clearly shows two dead bodies lying on the ground. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub Clause: 6. 1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.

 

November

Date Description of violation Clause violated
Nov. 02, 2021 Father allegedly rapes daughter of estate in Nuwara Eliya. Father’s name and place of incident mentioned. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub Clause 6.2: In reporting accounts of crime or criminal case, publications shall not, unless it is both legally permitted and in the public interest – i. Name victims of sex crimes. 
Clause 07. Privacy.
Sub clause 7.1:  The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals,
Nov. 16, 2021 Photograph of dead man as a result of an accident between a three wheeler and a motor bicycle. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub Clause: 6. 1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
Nov. 23, 2021 Photograph shows the body of a youth lying on the ground with relatives by the side while PCR is being carried out. Face of youth is easily distinguishable. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub Clause: 6. 1: The press should take special care to present facts, opinions, photographs and graphics with due sensitivity and discretion, subject to its duty to publish in the public interest.
Nov. 25, 2021 Woman drinks mosquito repellant (poison) and commits inside prison in Galle.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub clause 6.1: Excessive detail of the method used should not be disclosed.

 

December

Date Description of violation Clause violated
Dec. 17, 2021 Daughter raped by father at Despod, Kataragama, It mention father’s name and place of residence. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub Clause 6.2: In reporting accounts of crime or criminal case, publications shall not, unless it is both legally permitted and in the public interest – i. Name victims of sex crimes. 
Clause 07. Privacy
Sub clause 7.1: The press shall exercise particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals.
Dec. 17, 2021 Daughter raped by father at Despod, Kataragama, It mention father’s name and place of residence. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing.
Sub Clause 6.2: In reporting accounts of crime or criminal case, publications shall not, unless it is both legally permitted and in the public interest – i. Name victims of sex crimes. 
Clause 07. Privacy
Sub clause 7.1: Particular care to respect the private and family lives of individuals.
Dec. 17, 2021 A student of Girls’ High School in Mahanuwara commits suicide in the bathroom with the use of kerosene oil and setting herself ablaze.  Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.5: Care should be taken not to give excessive detail of the method used.
Dec. 20, 2021 Deceased female pre-school teacher is a Sinhalese. She was found dead in Kilinochchi. Clause 06. General Reporting and Writing
Sub clause: 6.4 (ii): The media should avoid publishing details of a person’s race, caste, religion etc., unless these are directly relevant to the story.   

 

-/end –

1 comment
admin
ADMINISTRATOR
PROFILE

Posts Carousel

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked with *

1 Comment

Latest Posts

Top Authors

Most Commented

Featured Videos